Teacher as Leader- Opportunity for Reflection

“Crow Island” (Dewey Classroom, Chicago 1940)

 

The older type of instruction tended to treat the teacher as a dictatorial ruler. The newer type sometimes treats the teacher as a negligible fact, almost as an evil, though a necessary one. In reality the teacher is the intellectual leader of a social group. He is a leader, not in virtue of official position, but because of a wider and deeper knowledge and matured experience. The supposition that the principle of freedom confers liberty upon the pupils, but that the teacher is outside of its range and must abdicate all leadership is merely silly.

 John Dewey (Later Works 8:337)

As a teacher, it can be daunting to understand one’s leadership role, especially when managing expectations for students as ordinary learning routines have been capsized by a pandemic.  Dewey warns such circumstances are the very time to avoid counterproductive, or merely either-or thinking. For instance, when faced with chaotic circumstances, a teacher may gravitate towards taking more control, as a dictator might, or release that control as classroom facilitator, letting students finish their own learning path without a navigator.

To Dewey, this either-or thinking for teachers is insufficient, and irresponsible; instead, he encourages educators to examine the moment of impasse as an opportunity to reflect and reshape one’s practice. The freedom Dewey offers teachers to lead, which authors Simpson, Jackson and Aycock explore in “The Teacher As Leader”,  is to seek intellectual clarity through social inquiry with others.  In particular, their essay explores and questions the teacher’s active role in suggesting or shaping “understandings, qualities of mind, and particular activities” to spur student inquiry.

Our efforts to seek social inquiry together make Fieldwork a messy and spontaneous space to learn. I am often surprised by the messiness of teaching community-based learning, but I always gravitate back to leading through intellectual inquiry, to apply shared understandings so we might make new knowledge.

If you are still searching for an idea to prompt your final fieldjournal reflection for Blog 7, I’m offering you the option of reading this essay on Dewey as a springboard for integrating your own thinking about how teachers lead, either the teacher you’ve been working with in the Rockbridge County Schools, or a teacher you’ve witnessed in your own educational history. I know that leadership is a relevant quality at VMI, but one I find needs further articulation to be understood in a variety of social contexts. As you read and interpret Dewey’s theories about leading in the classroom, you might consider one of these guiding questions:

According to Dewey’s modes of counterproductive thinking in the attached essay (Table 13:1, 178), in what ways have you experienced these modes in a learning setting?  How have you seen your teachers lead themselves or others into or out of these practices?

What common understandings, qualities or activities have you seen a teacher model or create in a classroom to define a shared intellectual purpose? (see Summative exercise on 187)

Are there any particular anecdotes or explanations Dewey offers that help you imagine the kinds of “productive thinking” (see 179) teachers should emulate in concert with their students and public affiliations?

 

ESSAY DOWNLOAD ATTACHED:

Dewey_TeacherAs Leader_SJ&A2005

 

 

How Do Kids Connect To Cartoons and Why Is It Important?

In Ian K. Macgillivray’s article entitled, “Using Cartoons to Teach Students about Stereotypes and Discrimination: One Teacher’s Lessons from South Park,” Macgillivray goes into extensive detail about various instructors’ utilization of cartoons in their classrooms. Elaborating on how students connect to cartoons Macgillivray states that, “Categorizing people by using a group label, in effect, highlights their similarities to one another and their differences from other people, which also “link[s] social groups to a whole constellation of other types of information” (Ehrlich, 2–3). In essence, stereotyping “makes it easier to store knowledge and to recall it” (Mcgillivray, 138). He also goes on to describe the four different reasons that he uses cartoons in the classroom. He asserts that “animated cartoons are an important part of popular culture… because cartoons are based on humor, they are especially apt texts for examining culture” and that “there is evidence that humor helps students to better process and accept information that negates stereotyping.” Moreover, and most importantly, “allowing students to identify with a cartoon character who is coming to terms with his or her own prejudices, which the student viewer may also hold, is less threatening in that it gives the student an opportunity to first see someone else (the cartoon character) going through the process of examining his or her own stereotypes.” Macgillivray then goes on to explain how other teachers use cartoons in their classroom by citing research that he uncovered regarding cartoons in classrooms.

These teachers discuss how the cartoons they used were effective, but they also gave warnings about how the overuse of cartoons can just perpetuate the negative stereotypes they portray as opposed to educating students. Macgillivray also explores in his article how analyzing the studies of cartoons over an expanse of time can help teachers tailor their lesson plans to their classes. Macgillivray dives into a number of studies including research regarding racial, gender, and LGBTQ+ stereotypes, as well as stereotypes regarding those with mental illnesses. This article is a great one to read, not only because it shows you how other teachers have used cartoons to teach kids about how to identify and engage with their biases, but because it also tells instructors how we relate to cartoons in such a way that allows us to project our biases onto the cartoon during class discussion and, in that projection, we feel safe from judgment because “it is what the illustrator is saying, not us.”

Collaborative Portrait: A Look into Maury River’s 8th Grade English Class

In the historic town of Lexington, the classrooms at Maury River Middle School are small, and the faces are familiar. The teachers stay incredibly involved, and know each and every one of their students personally. With Lexington being so small, teachers have the opportunity to get to know their students closely, and work together in the classroom. Throughout this semester, Mrs. Diette and her 8th grade English students have given my partner and I an in-depth look at a middle school environment here in the Shenandoah Valley.

Kirk and I first started in a helper class during Eagle Academy time in the mornings. For the first hour of school, students sit in a classroom that most students would call their “homeroom.” For most students, this can be time to relax and get ready for the day ahead. However, for the students that need it, this first period is critical in making sure that they are understanding the content being covered in other classes and are staying on top of their schoolwork. Not only was this interesting to observe, but it was not something that was provided during my time at middle school. This first period proved to be helpful for the students if they used their teacher and her resource correctly.

In Mrs. Diette’s English class during last period, where Kirk and I spent the remaining of the semester, the classroom appears to paint a clear picture upon first glance. Mrs. Diette has the week carefully planned out on the white board in the front of the class. Vocab words, posters, and literary devices are scattered throughout the classroom’s walls. A mini library sits in the corner of the classroom with the quote “books are a uniquely portable magic.” Mrs. Diette is in front of the classroom giving an upbeat presentation with some videos and pictures, and will most likely break the students off into collaborative groups soon. However, if you take a closer look at the students, it paints a blurrier picture. The students cannot seem to stay engaged. The laptops they have open in front of them are probably open to a game, and not the given assignment. The students do not feel the want to participate and answer questions in class, and conversations are being secretly had in the back of the classroom. For the students in Rockbridge county, the majority of them do not seem to have the “love of learning” that one may be able to see in a different classroom or school setting elsewhere.

In 2015, the “on-time high school graduation rate” for Lexington was at 92.4%, which was higher than the national average. As well, over 75% of those on time graduates, went on to attend a four-year college. Based on these positive statistics, it is interesting how Kirk and I observed quite the opposite inside an actual 8th grade classroom in Lexington. Are the laptops given out so early in middle school a distraction from the learning material? Is this how the last class of the day looks for a normal eighth grader?

Final Classroom Portrait of Rockbridge County and Mrs. Dowless 6th Grade Class

New Year, New Insights: Working Together to Make a Difference for ...

The learning environment of a Rockbridge County 6th grade classroom is filled with group learning, guided discussions, independent learning, and lectures. Additionally, the environment itself reflects so many of the major characteristics suggested by EL Education and Project Based Teaching, such as classroom Norms and many displays of individual expression. Though the Rockbridge county school system serves as a place to unite all of students, it is undeniable each student comes from a different background. The Community Academic Research Alliance at Washington and Lee University conducted an investigation into these matters, and according to their report entitled, “Poverty in Rockbridge,” many of Rockbridge County students come from impoverished households. However, there are also many students who benefit from the surrounding institutions, being VMI and W&L, either directly or indirectly. Accounting for the differences in student’s backgrounds, teachers and administrators must understand this perspective when enacting different strategies within their classroom and schools respectively.

In our experience, working in Mrs. Dowless’ 6th grade classroom, Maury River Middle School understands that and does well with implementing strategies that connect the students who vary widely. For one, the teachers invest in their students’ success and constantly stay aware of the varying abilities of those in their class, focusing on those who need help while allowing those who are better off to conduct more independent learning. Additionally, the classroom environment itself is conducive to learning and interactive learning through the organization of the tables, easily moveable and put in small groups, and a classroom pet which makes the classroom more inviting. On top of that, the school as a whole does well implementing technology, specifically centered around computers, into their curriculum. They assisted those who may be less fortunate with providing loaner Chromebooks so all students can have the same educational experience regardless of their background. Though an educational environment may always have room for improvement, Rockbridge County’s Maury River Middle School is on the right path towards fostering success for their students.

With the onset of the Coronavirus pandemic, everything has changed, for both us and our partner teacher. Specifically in the Rockbridge County environment, the movement from class in person to class online greatly  affects our ability to connect with students who may either need the extra motivation or have a poor home life and need a place away from home to do their learning. In addition to those factors, as mentioned before, some students may not have access to a computer or the internet at home, which again inhibits their learning. Accounting for those factors, teachers are working hard to figure out ways to circumvent those challenges. For Mrs. Dowless, she is currently utilizing google classroom to try and reproduce the positive classroom environment that she had at school. a completely new environment. As the pandemic continues on, this struggle will continue on and  the Rockbridge County school system will continually try to recreate the positive environment that they successfully create in their schools.

 

Works Cited

“Poverty in Rockbridge.” Washington and Lee University, my.wlu.edu/the-shepherd-program/academics/community-academic-research-alliance-(cara)/rockbridge-community-profile/poverty-in-rockbridge.

 

Who are these students?

When first going into Ms.Dowless’ sixth grade science class, our priority was to focus on the classroom environment. We wanted to see how the learning process worked and connected it to our own experience of middle school. When we first were able to converse and interact with the students, it seemed like they were your normal middle schoolers. It can be easy for instructors to just do their job and teach their lesson plans, but will this be meaningful? Over our years within academia, we have been able to realize the teachers who had a more personable connection seemed to get more of our effort and attention. But in order to develop this personable connection, instructors must understand who they are teaching. Rockbridge county is very different than where we are from: Richmond, VA and Aberdeen, NC.

Well, at least that’s what we thought as we observed the landscape and demographic around us. Before doing research on Rockbridge county, we had an objective view that it was just a rural agricultural area, filled with a majority Caucasian demographic. By seeing a majority of Caucasians, we assumed the county had to be decently well off. After reading data from the U.S. Census and the Virginia Department of Education, we now know there isn’t that big of a difference between where we grew up and Rockbridge. The area including Lexington, Rockbridge, and Buena Vista have a median income significantly lower than the other parts of Virginia. In the city of Lexington, around 17% of the population receives food stamps from the government. Within the school system itself, almost 70% of the students are eligible for free or reduced lunch and almost half are eligible for free or reduced breakfast. We are glad to have discovered this information because if we ever go into the classroom again in the future, there will be a different approach. We would talk to the students and ask about their lives outside of school. We would try and develop a relationship that shows we care if they’re experiencing hardships at home.  This is important to us because realistically students spend more time with teachers than their families. The connection between students and teachers is key, and it starts by teachers understanding where their students come from.

Blog 6 Draft and Teach-in recording

 

Casey Marchant

ERH-411

21 March 2020

HR: Observation notes and Field Journals. VDOE website (links in works referenced)

Classroom Portrait Draft

The Classroom situation we are in is an Honors 9th Grade English class. The teacher is relatively young. The classroom itself is very laid back with an attempt to bring positivity and encouragement all over the room. Additionally, it is focused during class time but it isn’t extremely strict. The learner portrait is a bit more difficult for me to create as I really didn’t get much of any experience with the students other than a very short activity where the only conversation is on what they were learning and what the activity was. I can say that they are in an honors class so it is safer to assume that there is a little bit more motivation internally. As for what I saw, there was a significant amount of engagement and it did not seem like the students were interested in anything other than what was going on in class. From the start of the class to the time that I left everyone was focused and on the ball with the material that was being covered. Moreover, this is even more impressive as this class is the first one of the day and typically it can take a couple hours for the mind to really get going. All of the students seemed relatively competent in the aspects of what they are learning. Motivated, interested, engaged, and competent is the learner’s profile that we are dealing with. This may have something to do with what the teacher brings to the table Mrs. Holton is young and has had only a few years of experience. She is local both in where she was raised and went to her primary education and where she went to college. Being an alumni of James Madison University her life shows that there is a connection to the Shenandoah valley and Rockbridge county. Additionally, her energy and enthusiasm for her profession shows that she has a serious interest in educating the young people in her class. If she is apathetic about the progress of youth in the community then she hides it well.

Once we take a step back from the specific from the class room and look at the school as a whole we can start putting this environment into context. If you look at the statistics provided by the VDOE the SOL pass rate for Rockbridge high school is not bad. For all students out of the tested subject matters two have a 90+ pass rating, Two have in the 80s pass rate, and the lowest, mathematics, has a 77 percent pass rate.  Breaking these testing scores into sub categories based on race, gender, economic status, and english language ability there are some definite patterns. For example Black students perform higher in two categories but slightly lower in the three others. Economically disadvantaged perform lower in all subjects and hispanics and english learners score well below average. Females score higher. Males and whites score average in all subjects. These statistics are indicators that while this school doesn’t do terribly there are certain groups without a doubt need more attention. Finally, the amount of students that accumulated more than 7 unexcused absences in 2018-2019 in the entirety of the Rockbridge county school system numbered 65. These statistics, however, do not seem to affect time graduation rates or dropout rates terribly. This school is only slightly under the state average for on time graduation.  This number is not terrible, however, it is not great. It sets lower in ranking them other school districts but this is the raw number, meaning that it does account for the size of the districts. Unfortunately, I do not have the tools to calculate or find the ratio but judging from the raw truancy count this is only a minor issue for this school system.

Overall, Rockbridge county school and Rockbridge county highschool is not bad but it also has some issues. My judgement from my point of view is that it is a very average school for Virginia. That being said there is far more information that could be looked at to be more accurate but I simply do not have the time or ability to use it. My classroom, however, was good and certainly can foster some great experiences and set students up for success well especially because it is a 9th grade class and can teach good habits early on.

Word Count: 732

Works Referenced:

http://www.doe.virginia.gov/statistics_reports/sol-pass-rates/index.shtml

http://www.doe.virginia.gov/statistics_reports/graduation_completion/cohort_reports/index.shtml

http://www.doe.virginia.gov/statistics_reports/school_climate/index.shtml

 

Is it Time to Incorporate Phone Usage in a Learning Environment (blog 5)

Article: web.b.ebscohost.com.vmiezproxy.vmi.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=4&sid=b45b177b-55c8-4762-b707-4388907dee1c%40pdc-v-sessmgr04

The scholarship I am recommending to Mrs. Diette is a position paper on the use of phones in the classroom published by Jennifer Cassidy. Despite the use of iPads, laptops, and chrome books readily available to most students nowadays, Cassidy recommends that mobile devices should be added into the mix in order to “place learning in the student’s hands.”

Drawing on a study from 2017 on the misuse of phones in the classroom, Cassidy puts the blame on the teachers. She claims that an instructor’s behavior directly impacts inappropriate cell phone use in the classroom. If a teacher fails to keep the students engaged in the activity, students feel an increasing need to reach for their phones due to boredom. Since students already want to reach for their phones in class, Cassidy claims that teachers can capitalize on the opportunity and use it to their advantage, stating that “the use of texting or social media in the curriculum should be viewed as an opportunity to engage students, not something to ban.”

We are in an increasing technological world, and cell phones are capable of doing much more than they were able to just a few short years ago. Cassidy postulates an opportunity for teachers to reach students through a more familiar mode, and comes to the conclusion that teachers will be able to reach more students of different learning styles. Her argument is well researched and raises important questions in the educational community; should we get rid of the stigma behind cell phone use in the classroom? Her argument is very convincing, and the research she has done is extremely valuable for Mrs. Diette’s 8th graders at Maury River Middle School. Kirk and I have recognized that a majority of the students have an issue staying engaged in class, and the laptops they currently have do not seem to benefit them, Perhaps a more familiar form of technology would allow teachers to reach students better, and keep them motivated during the class periods.

Online Learning Through Troubling Times

The scholarly article that I found for Mrs. Cosgriff is Transformation through expeditionary change using online
learning and competence-building technologies by Donald M. Morris and Paul Lefrere.  The purpose of the scholarly article is to demonstrate a model of the usage of technology for expeditionary learning and how technology is involved with teaching currently. I believe that this article will be good for Mrs. Cosgriff and her fifth grade classroom as they navigate online learning and the struggles that come along with it. I imagine that this is tough for the fifth grade students to go from a expeditionary based learning environment on immigration to distant online schooling. The struggles that Mrs. Cosgriff will have to deal with are non cooperative parents as well as lack of technology in certain households. This article will give some insight how she will be able to maintain a expeditionary learning teaching style while doing online classes.

From the start of the article I noticed that Morris and Lefrere are focused on “higher education” and employability of the students. The article’s focus on expeditionary learning through an online venue is focused on higher education not primary education. This is great to focus on overall but is not applicable for Mrs. Cosgriff. Morris and Lefrere state that teachers should “replicate courses and curriculum practices in an online mode, adjusting for differences between online and face-to-face experiences. ” This would be a great way for Mrs. Cosgriff to translate the course work she was doing in the classroom before the Covid-19 pandemic to now. Joe and I received and email about the struggles that Mrs. Cosgriff was already enduring with the first few weeks of preparing for a possible school shutdown and getting a course schedule ready for it. Though I think this article will be insightful, I am not sure it focuses on the challenges that will come up with implementing an online course in a rural community. In the conclusion, Morris and Lefrere harps that the important aspect of this article is for the teachers and educational community to “focus on outcomes and value, not processes and quality.” Overall, I believe this article will help with some aspects as Mrs. Cosgriff transitions from face-to-face learning to online.

Work Cited:

Donald M. Norris & Paul Lefrere (2011) Transformation through Expeditionary Change Using Online Learning and Competence-building Technologies, Research in Learning Technology, 19:1, 61-72, DOI: 10.1080/09687769.2010.549205

A Theoretical Frame Work for Environmental Education in Practice

Riordan and Klein’s “Environmental Education in Action: How Expeditionary Learning Schools Support Classroom Teachers in Tackling Issues of Sustainability” study published in Teacher Education Quarterly was a perfect fit for what my group is attempting to do with the Maury River Middle School Eco Council. What the study aimed to look for was to look at the work of an organization that works to support teacher’s efforts in the ever growing and more important movement of Environmental Education. Their goal was to “promote the development of responsive and active citizens who are invested in environmental issues and situations, and who are empowered by their ownership of knowledge and skills”. What the essay describes is what the 10 design principles of Expeditionary Learning in schools are. The research promotes and explores sustainable school practices through specific case studies of how expeditionary learning promoted environmental based education and impact student experience and work. This essay provides the necessary theoretical framework needed for our project at Maury River Middle School as it creates the basis for the learning experiences for teachers and for students. It integrates environment education for sustainable development into our proposal and how we seek to see it through. The model provided will let us build an assignment grounded in peer reviewed research that will better enable us to produce quality work. The best way to show these frameworks is to integrate them into our own project. What this will look like is creating an assignment that fulfills the core requirements that expeditionary learning in environmental education tries to instill. The essay shows the importance of teachers engaging in field research in environmental education. In our project what that could mean is that instead of having teachers simply guide discussions, they too should participate as a model for what quality work looks like in environmental education.

 

Works Cited

Riordan, Meg Klein, J. Emily ““Environmental Education in Action: How Expeditionary Learning Schools Support Classroom Teachers in Tackling Issues of Sustainability”. Teacher Education Quarterly. 2010

Inspiration for all levels

Book review of Teaching literacy in the digital age: Inspiration for all levels and literacies by Joy Myers and Melissa Adams-Budde provide a detailed and well thought out review of how Mark Gura formulated this book. They state that

Each chapter in the book highlights specific ideas rather than providing lesson plans in order to be applicable to a larger audience, and each is authored by a current classroom teacher or support staff who works directly with teachers (769).

 

Teaching literacy in the digital age: Inspiration for all levels and literacies is divided into five sections: (1) ‘‘Reinforcing reading and writing with video and audio’’; (2) ‘‘Analyzing and discussing literature’’; (3) ‘‘Story writing’’; (4) ‘‘Persuasive and argumentative writing’’; and (5) ‘‘And even more inspiration’’. Each section helps organize and embrace the new style of teaching. For instance, in section 1, Myers and Budde express that each chapter highlights how teachers can use video and audio in their teachings to drive home the basic reading and writing information (770).  One point I found interesting was Myers and Budde’s section 3 review. They state

Section 3 focus on activities related to story writing in middle and high school classrooms. These include graphic novel writing projects, interactive fiction and the relationship between comics and performance. According to the authors, there are several benefits of using a graphic novel writing format, including that stories can be told in non-traditional ways and that it is a motivating genre for students (770-771).

 

This is important because it gives students the ability to create and mold their thoughts into creations that could become masterpieces and inspire people coming in behind them.

I believe the biggest takeaway is not what the students produce, but the process of producing their masterpieces and how it effects the generation behind them. Our education system is missing that the process is more important than the product. Putting a grade on how a student thinks, responds, or creates is in itself a disservice to their growth and their education as a whole. Focusing on the product opens the gate for shortcuts, cheating, and short-term learning. The information I took from this reading is that we as a country are failing all around and if we really want to make a change, we should focus on the process rather than the product.

 

Work Cited

  1. Myers, Joy, and Melissa Adams-Budde. “Teaching Literacy in the Digital Age: Inspiration for All Levels and Literacies.” International Review of Education / Internationale Zeitschrift Für Erziehungswissenschaft, vol. 63, no. 5, Oct. 2017, pp. 769–772. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1007/s11159-017-9649-y.