Prompt 2 – Steinberg

I think the author chose this form to establish how Barbie herself has kind of changed how people think of history in itself because of the multiple forms she has taken on since her creation. She plays the part of standard, perfect Barbie, to a Barbie that represents different cultures and ethnicities with respect to different events in history as well as the present. Steinberg directly states, “Maybe I am taking an artist’s license in rewriting scriptures. It only seemed appropriate, as Mattel has been rewriting history and children’s play for years” (18). Just like many children, especially in the ‘90s, were raised reading and learning through the Bible, many also learned through Barbie. Barbie is timeless, just like the Bible.

 

Steinberg’s rendition “Book of the Generations of Barbie” begins with the institution of Barbie herself, followed with how she evolved through time, with the introduction of elements including different races, ethnicities, and cultures. Steinberg describes Barbie as the perfect image of the American dream – “the bitch has everything.” She shows kids that if you work hard enough, you can achieve anything, an almost unrealistic persona. Steinberg also critiques that the “normal” Barbie has no additional label or description, whereas other versions of the children’s doll has specific names paired with their editions, for example: Indian Barbie, Jamaican Barbie, Police Officer Barbie, Sergeant Barbie… These labels signify, as Steinberg points out, that Barbie without a label should be viewed as the normal or standard for our society.

 

WC: 240

Prompt 1-Harney and Frost

From Harney’s “A Strange Land and a Peculiar People” and Frost’s “Our Contemporary Ancestors in the Southern Mountains,” I can agree that ways they discussed Appalachian people could be problematic.

Harney describes people of his journey to have “quaint speech and patient poverty” (1). He explains how isolated the people are due to geography: progression of community suffered, along with vernacular of the people. Harney also criticizes how the “influence of the moon” is still believed to be responsible for vegetation, and the methods of which they go about farming, specifically with iron. He states, “In all such cases the failures are unrecorded, while the successes are noted, wondered at and published. By shooting arrows all day, even a blind man may hit the mark sometimes” (3). He argues that glorifying unique methods is invalid if they don’t work majority of the time.

Frost argues that the remoteness of Appalachian societies resulted from people “unconsciously [stepping] aside from the great avenues of commerce and thought” (1).  He uses “illiterate, moonshiners, homicides… poor white trash” to describe people he encounters, and states these societies provide ways of “measuring [our] progress of the moving world” (3). He criticizes the “absence of convenience” in everything they make or do (2). He does, however, point out the sense of “initiative” people hold to live functionally, especially if venturing to modern-day America (8).

Both Harney and Frost refer to the people of Appalachia almost as if they’re a different species and are not respectful of the peoples’ ways of everyday life.

 

WORD COUNT: 256

Reflective Essay

A Reflection of Biology of Gender: Promoting Awareness and Inclusion

I entered this class eager to learn about gender in culture. I’ve always been supportive of people fully committing to themselves 100% of the time. I had been exposed to much of the LGBTQ+ community through my background in theatre before coming to VMI this past year. Until the end of senior year, I was on track to be studying acting in New York City or Boston, but decided VMI would provide me a unique experience that would build the most and best character over the next few years. Because I was so involved in theatre within my school and community, I was introduced around my time in middle school to individuals who commit to being themselves 100% of the time, and many of these people have been my best friends since. Through my friendship with them, I have learned to fully embrace myself as a way to encourage others to do the same. As a straight, little white girl, I’ve felt it’s sometimes hard to actually have a voice that’s heard in these discussions, but with every day I try to get to know myself and others better to create an inclusive community for all.

After the first class, I had learned the differences and definitions of gender and sex; previously, I had thought the words were merely interchangeable. The class discussion taught me an individual’s sex had to do with one’s biological and reproductive organs, chemical balances, hormones, and sex chromosomes. The term gender refers to how an individual identifies themselves and how social constructs shape him or her – it’s more than anatomy. Gender identity and gender expression were also topics mentioned in this class discussion. Gender identity refers to how an individual perceives themselves. Gender expression is physical; it’s what the public can see. Gender identity is private, and reaches beyond visibility. Terminology is important; it’s difficult but important. Sex and gender, along with gender identity and expression, have been terms I have previously used interchangeably, and often at that. Now that I’m aware of the differences, I will promote awareness among others as well (Artifact 1).

Also addressed in Artifact 1 was gender dysphoria. Gender dysphoria was formally referred to as a gender disorder. There is no such thing as a gender disorder. Gender dysphoria should not be treated as a disease. It is important to promote awareness of correct terminology, especially with gender grammar and gender pronouns. I believe in promoting a community in which both sides of the spectrum are involved with both educating and being educated. This endorses an understanding from both “victims” and the “accused,” even though ideally there really is no victim or accused individual. All people should be encouraged to be themselves: who they truly what to be, without the worry of judgment from others (Artifact 1).

Further in this course, we discussed the third gender and the meaning behind it. Individuals can now identify as neither man nor woman, making them the third gender. The gender binary refers to two distinct, separate sexes, the male and female, and the specific expectations, social constructs, and stereotypes of the two. In societies today all over the world, gender norms are constantly being expanded as people have realized how constraining they have become to the progression and advancement of individuals, civilizations, and nations. In history, the third gender has often been neglected and not accepted. Lives of sex trade and prostitution have been a popular, unsafe path for many third gender individuals who have been kicked out of their homes as a result of not being accepted. We studied different cultures, and the role of the third gender as they have become more accepted. For example, in India, the ancient transgender community of Hijra are viewed highly in the culture and are associated with gods and deities (Artifact 4).

In this course, we also studied how different genders affect individual roles in different societies (Artifact 2). The Global Gender Gap (Artifact 3) as well as the Gender Health Gap (Artifact 5) also help play a major role in how individuals can contribute to society because of differences among the genders and among different parts of the world. The Global Gender Gap refers to the measure of gender equality in different nations. According to the Global Gender Gap Report of 2015, the United States ranks number 28 out of 145 countries, and is ranked number 33 by Save the Children for best/worst countries to be a mother. Countries in the top ten of these lists are mostly European, while countries in the bottom ten are developing, third world countries in Africa. The responsibilities of men and women in Africa are far different than those of individuals in Europe and the United States (Artifact 3).

The gender health gap, though it has been greatly reduced over recent years, is still prevalent in affecting equal opportunity for all individuals and genders. In history, women were often overlooked for many research studies, both medical and nonmedical, unless the study directly or only applied to them. The biological differences between men and women should not lead to an excuse for inequality and unfair treatment. These differences should be taken into account when making steps towards offering equal playing fields for all individuals. The most important thing to take from this, and many of the lessons we stumble upon everyday, is the significance of awareness (Artifact 5).

Whether man, woman, or third gender, all individuals are created differently. We all have different strengths and weaknesses, whether it’s what we were born with or what we’ve worked hard to achieve. We should all have control over our own bodies, have the ability to choose the paths we want most in our lives, and have the voice to help make our world a better, more accepting, inclusive place. This course provided me, and my classmates, with a foundation that has educated us to both be aware and promote awareness.

 

Artifact 7: Menstruation

The step that defines girls becoming women in many cultures world wide is menarche. Reactions differ worldwide. Some cultures celebrate a girl entering these early stages of adulthood; other cultures completely shame the young women, viewing them as unholy and unclean during this time of the month. Negative views with menstruation come along with the suppression of female’s sexuality. We can work to develop a more positive view of menstruation by embracing sexuality and encouraging more discussion on the topic of menstruation, periods, and how women can advance in life safely.

In places like Africa and India, feminine products and menstrual supplies are limited or absent from society. As a female, I could not imagine life without tampons. Females in these cultures are often shunned for a week, kept away from men, and sometimes forbidden to eat or drink certain products. The Jewish Orthodox religion has rules about marriage and menstruation. Some of these rules include sleeping on separate beds, no physical contact for two weeks. When these rules were made, it is explained that the Torah was trying to attempt women, as no knowledge about hygiene or health was yet known. While some may view these practices as oppressive, some find it empowering and strengthening to a relationship. One woman describes, “the most corny things become meaningful,” as man and woman are not even allowed to directly pass objects to each other. It is also the woman’s duty to cleanse herself after the sunsets at the end of her cycle.

Worldwide, many women have different feelings towards their menstrual cycles. Some fear it or are ashamed to talk about the natural process. Many women are delighted when the flow comes, as it means they are not pregnant. Many just find it annoying and tedious: it’s a lot to take care of physically and women are often pissy or unusually sad for a week or so.

 

Reflective tag: Periods are natural. People, men and women alike, should not be afraid of the process or afraid of the conversations of them. While they’re annoying and tedious, they’re essential for life. Different cultures and societies have different practices regarding a woman’s time of the month, but one of the most important parts is the safety of women during this time in regards to hygiene and care for their cycles.

Artifact 8: Half the Sky

This movie addresses the issue of women controlling their own bodies. Specific issues include gender-based violence, sex trafficking, education, maternal mortality, intergenerational prostitution, and economic opportunities. In countries such as Sierra Leone, not even 1% of individuals involved with gender-based violence have been convicted. 90% of Sierra Leone’s population have an STD, and while war in the country ended in 2002, women are still raped, 26% of which are under 12 years old. Sex trafficking is also a problem. This is a problem in Cambodia. Activists are working to not only stop sex trafficking but also to educate but men and women on safer sex and contraceptives.

Maternal mortality is also a huge problem in today’s world. For example, Somaliland has one of the highest mortality rates. One in every twelve women die in childbirth. Most women are expected to have eight to ten babies in their lifetime. Children are circumcised between the ages of five and eight. Intergenerational prostitution in India is also a huge problem. Of the 300 million individuals subjected to intergenerational prostitution, 1.2 million of them are children. The average age that young girls become involved in prostitution is between 9 to 13 years old. Many of the “brokers” kill their victims. A way work to solve or make steps towards stopping prostitution in India is to make attendance to public school mandatory.

Artifact 6: Male and Female Circumcision

Female circumcision involves the cutting, alteration or mutilation of female genitals. There are many different types of female circumcision. Type I involves partial or total removal of the clitoris. Type II involves partial of total removal of the labia minora, along with removal of the clitoris. Type III involves the sewing together of the labia majora in order to cover both the urethra and vagina, removal of the labia minora, and removal of the clitoris. Type III is also called infibulation or pharaonic circumcision and has been outlawed in many countries. Many justify this process in saying that it encourages better hygiene, preserves virginity and protects against unwanted pregnancies, and upholds family honor and faithfulness. Origins of this practice are both religious and cultural.

Many complications and side effects come along side with this practice. Scarring and pregnancy and childbirth problems are some of the many. However, a girl who did not have her clitoris removed was considered unlucky and fatal to both her family and lover. Educating cultures about the negatives affects and consequences of female circumcision has been tried, but the subject is still extremely controversial in many communities and cultures, especially in countries like Somalia, Sudan, Mali, Guinea, and Egypt.

Male circumcision involves the removal of the foreskin. In some places in African and Australia, it is considered a right of passage, and it is also a common practice among certain religions such as Judaism and Islam. According to WHO about 33% of the world’s males are circumcised. Circumcision has no effect on sex and risks are rare; the practice can reduce prostate cancer, UTIs, STDs, and can reduce the risk of HIV. Male circumcision can be performed both by surgical and nonsurgical processes. A nonsurgical method would take about a week to complete. Controversies over this subject include the ideas that the baby himself should choose, at a more mature age, and that foreskin is not a birth defect.

 

Reflective Tag: Circumcision for males and females is very different. For males, a lot of benefits can be found; it can protect from STDs and help reduce the chances of getting other STDs, UTIs, and even prostate cancer. Female circumcision is a bit more extreme, and tends to aim for this idea of preservation and purity. Overall, I believe whosever body it is should have the choice to do what they want with it. Knowing that all cultures see things through a different lens, it is my hope that the world is continually educated on circumcision and its effects, both positive and negative.

Film Assignment

Men and women alike are imprisoned by stereotypes. There is an ideal image that has been set by today’s society for each gender, constantly pressuring individuals to change who they are to be something or someone they are not. This involves all mental and physical aspects of life for both male and females. Typically, males are thought of as strong, emotionless leaders, while females are called upon to cater to and support males. In the documentary Pornland, the idea of girls choosing to be either “fuckable vs. invisible” is presented. With this, there really is no choice for females. Porn culture has shaped the mind of boys and men, starting as early as age 11, to think of women through a lens focused on sex. Porn, as the documentary describes, defaces and dehumanizes women, and is progressively getting more and more violent. Porn takes away of freedom of creating our own sexuality, for both male and females.

The documentary Guyland discusses the transition from boyhood to manhood. As times have changed, a new stage of development, between adolescence and adulthood, has developed: adultolescence. Whereas in the past people would go straight into the workforce, the transition is now noted to take at least a full decade longer with education, marriage, children, moving, and job finding, as well as a heavy dependency on parents. With this new stage, women have stood up for themselves, become key members of the work place, giving themselves new identities and conquering the traditional, modest stereotypes that have been placed for decades. For men, ideas of masculinity have not changed. With this comes hazing and other methods to “prove” one’s manliness to other men. There’s a constant pressure for both sexes to strive to be this ideal image. But more recently, people have become aware of how detrimental this ideal image can be for the progression of individuals and societies as a whole. It can cause harm to health, physically and mentally, and is plain unrealistic for many people. With each day, I feel like, individualism is being encouraged more as we become further aware of how important it is to be ourselves and make our own contributions to better our societies.

 

Artifact 5: Gender Health Gap

The gender health gap has been greatly reduced in recent years, but activists are still working for equality. Factors other than gender important to note for the health gap include age, socioeconomic factors, and race. In respect to health treatments, men and women have been treated differently in the past. With a traditionally paternalistic relationship with doctors, it may have been hard for women to speak up and address what help they really need. Birth control and other contraceptives were not always legal; only married women whose husbands approved could take birth control pills until 1972. When abortion, an ongoing, heated topic and conversation today, was illegal, it was the cause of more deaths than actually birthing the child.

In the past, women were often overlooked for many research studies, unless the topic directly or only applied to them. As man and wife, rape was legal, and men could objectify females in the workplace by sexually harassing them physically or firing them for not invalid actions such as not having sex with the man. Times are changing, however, as present day researchers and doctors have realized that women are in fact not “little men.” Women function differently but deserve equal opportunity and access to what they may need.

Research collected by the New York Times states that men have a lower life expectancy with higher rates of injuries, suicides, and death from chronic illness. It is also identified that a man’s pride may get in the way of a yearly check up or visit to a doctor. Gender transformative interventions promote lifestyles that steer away from gender-norms. These interventions endorse equal health care and treatment, blind to sex and gender.

 

Reflective tag: The differences between men and women should not lead to a health gap of inequality and unfair treatment. It is good that this has been brought to everyone’s attention and that there is constantly work being done to improve and close the gap. It is important for women as well as men to realize the importance of their health and seek the help they need when it’s needed. Timeliness is key, being both the doctors’ and patients’ responsibility.

Artifact 4: The Third Gender

Gender binary refers to two distinct, separate sexes (male and female) and the specific expectations and stereotypes of the two. Examples of going outside gender binaries range from a female ordering a beer and a burger (rather than a sweet, mixed drink and a salad) or being attracted to members of the same sex. Today’s societies norms for genders are constantly being expanded, as people have realized how constraining they have become.

Individuals who identify as neither man nor woman identify as third gender.  Native American societies, India, and Thailand, among many others, will recognize the third gender on forms of identification. India’s ancient transgender community of Hijra formally identify as neither male nor female. Often, these individuals have lived a life of neglect and hardship before becoming a Hijra. An estimate of two million Hijra live in India today. Hijra, or the transgender society, are viewed highly and are associated with the gods and deities of the culture. A newly wedded couple, as well as babies and small children, come to Hijra for advice and blessings.

Many neglect and abuse the third gender. As a result of not being accepted by friends and family, many transgender individuals have been kicked out of their households and have turned to lives of sex trade and prostitution.

 

Reflective Tag: The third gender is real, and it’s unfortunate that people choose to ignore them, and in turn for those who are not accepted by society for simply identify with who they truly feel they are.

Artifact 3: The Global Gender Gap

The Global Gender Gap refers to the measure of gender equality in different nations. The United States ranks number 28 on the Global Gender Gap index according to the Global Gender Gap Report 2015, out of 145 countries. Save the Children rates the best and worst countries to be a mother: Norway being number one, and Somalia being number 179. The United States ranks number 33 according to Save the Children in this area. Many of the countries in the top 10, excluding Australia, are European. All of the countries on the bottom ten’s list are developing, third world countries in Africa.

Availability and quality of health care could contribute to the wellbeing of women and the gender gaps within these societies. Health care, birth control, and contraceptives are easier to access in Europe, even in comparison to the United States. Political and religious issues cause disagreements on what should and should not be available for women in the United States, leaving us behind other countries such as Norway, Finland, and Iceland, the top three countries to be a mother. The U.S. could improve its ranking by improving health care for women.

The responsibilities of women in African cultures are far different than those of women in Europe and the United States. These responsibilities and expectations affect the lower ranking; the birth rate is also higher in African nations because of the lack of contraceptives and health care availability.

 

Reflective Tag: Countries with health care easily accessible for women have higher rankings. This is why the U.S. lags so far behind countries such as Spain, the Netherlands, Sweden, Australia, and Germany. Countries ranked on the bottom ten for worst countries to be a mother lack sufficient health care and place high levels of stress on mothers.