In the following essay I observe and analyze classic American literary practices both classically and presently. By providing historical and literary context for authors Charlotte Perkins Gillman and Victor Sejour, I explain where certain American, gothic conventions originate. I then explain the influences of such conventions by analyzing a contemporary piece of entertainment, Shutter Island, and the ways in which the film’s trailer employs some of these gothic tools.
The American gothic genre is a brash tool that has been boldly used to express mental, political, and emotional opinions. It also served as an intellectual stepping stone from authors who left a huge mark on the American literature legacy. What I’ve come to believe over the course of the semester was that the most effective and common tool used by these influential writers was the reflection on oppression and its societal, as well as mental, effects. Between mental illness, slavery, and the general oppression of women, Charlotte Perkins Gillman, Victor Sejour, and more recently Martin Scorsese all make subtle commentaries about the suppression of identity and purpose through their use of general gothic conventions. By not only reading the works of these American authors but also learning who and what kind of people they are, I discovered what kind of motive an author needs to confront such a dark topic like oppression in such eloquent ways. After analyzing the gothic conventions they used and comparing them to the more modern example of my Shutter Island trailer analysis, I found common threads between the older and the newer works.
Charlotte Perkins Gilman was an author who lived between 1860 and 1935. She committed suicide after receiving a diagnosis of inoperable breast cancer, but not before she published plenty of both fiction and non-fiction works. In each of her pieces, she aimed to incite support for feminism and social reform. While researching her for my author presentation I discovered that she had suffered through a case of serious depression, at which point she was given the “rest cure,” which inspired her fictional short story, “The Yellow Wallpaper.” I pieced together the frustration she must have felt and its direct correlation to the frustration and insanity the protagonist develops in the story. Both oppressors in the story are male and speak to the protagonist like she is a child, or insane, and it is clear that Gilman developed a strong resentment for this behavior and used it to generalize the social attitude towards women at the time, as well as towards the mentally ill. In my first artifact, my presentation, “Charlotte Perkins Gilman,” I explained that the story “depicts the escape of women from the pressures of a seemingly unwanted marriage.” I also commented on what motivated her as a writer, saying she was a “feminist/social reformist, writer, she denied traditional female roles, and she was a women’s rights activist.” I better understood Gilman’s distaste for female oppression after reading “The Yellow Wallpaper,” and I better understood the story after taking her character into consideration.
Victor Sejour remarks on oppression in a similar way with his work, only he focuses on a different group of people being oppressed. In my second artifact, “Confronting the Horrors of Slavery,” I wrote about Sejour’s short story, “The Mulatto.” In the story, Sejour makes insinuations on the ultimate effects of oppression. Oppression in this instance is slavery, and the effects are virtually insanity, or losing one’s self. In my second artifact, I comment on the process of being enslaved and slowly going mad. “Through this process, we lose our humanity. By enslaving someone, you’ve taken away that humanity.” Sejour understands that being oppressed in this sense is being held down and enslaved by pure evil. Again in my second artifact, I also claim that “Georges is human and susceptible to the effects of evil in this world.” Georges is a slave who “belongs” to a torturous, evil man, who he does not know is his father. From practically using Georges as a human shield, to raping his wife, to having her executed, the man takes everything from Georges, even after Georges dedicated and risked his life for him. Georges eventually goes insane and loses his humanity out of hatred, vengeance, and spite, exactly like the protagonist in “The Yellow Wallpaper.” And similarly to “The Yellow Wallpaper,” I analyzed “The Mulatto” and promptly confirmed the dark effects of oppression. Although I cannot ever possibly empathize with this feeling of losing yourself, I can at least begin to remotely understand what may happen if I were to experience it, especially under such cruel experiences of loss and tragedy. Again, through analyzing the author and the story, I discovered one of the evils that motivates American, gothic literature.
Although it is not literature, Martin Scorsese directed the film Shutter Island, a movie which employs gothic themes and conventions. In the movie however, Scorsese does not only suggest the loss of humanity as an effect of oppression, but he takes it a step further and focuses on the oppression of mental illness itself, and how a mentally ill person is not considered a person at all, but an expendable life; a life that is not even human. Scorsese uses the trailer to interest the audience by ultimately leaving it scared, confused, and with a sense of desire to understand what the movie will try to convey. In my third artifact, “Shutter Island Trailer Analysis,” I comment on the setting of the film. “The story takes place in a mental institution for the criminally insane, on an island which is far enough away from other land that it gives the illusion of being completely alone and helpless.” From watching and analyzing the film trailer, I observed the behaviors and commentary on the mentally ill patients and noticed the severe mistreatment and belittlement they undergo, or at least underwent. Even being unaware of Scorsese’s prior opinion on the matter, it is evident that he wants to address and draw attention to the inhumane treatment of mentally ill patients in the past, and possibly the present and future. I was able to use my analysis skills from earlier literary works in the course to analyze the facets which Scorsese uses to convey a sense of dread and distaste. By the end of the actual film itself, one has a sense of pity and sympathy for the residents of the hospital; similar to the pity and sympathy felt for the woman in “The Yellow Wallpaper,” and the man in “The Mulatto.”
Throughout the semester, I not only learned about the evils and darkness of the human psyche, but discovered a sense of empathy inside my own heart for those who succumb to it, especially those who have no control in the matter. As I previously claimed, I cannot relate to the feeling of oppression because I have not been oppressed to the sharp degree in which the individuals in the literary works we covered in class have; but I am no longer oblivious to what motivates authors to write what they do, and why they feel the need to share it.
Help Received: none
Sarah Elizabeth Lemon